Recruitment and selection in Human Resource Management.
Recruitment and selection in Human
Resource Management
In an organization the knowledge and skills of an
employee towards the job description plays a major role in the success of that organization’s
goals achievement and growth. New innovations brought to light by employees
with a high IQ have prospectively helped the growth of many organizations world
wide. There fore choosing the right candidate to do the right job is a huge
responsibility of the organization’s human resource management division.
Compared with other areas in organisational management, relatively little academic work has focused on how different firms approach and should approach hiring decisions (Oyer & Schaefer 2011). Recruitment and selection of employees in an organization plays a huge fundamental role in accomplishing its missions to achieve its vision. According to Armstrong (2005) recruitment is the process of finding and engaging the people the organization needs. Selection is that part of the recruitment process concerned with deciding which applicants or candidates should be appointed to a specific job (Armstrong, 2005). "Human Resource Management theories described on techniques of recruitment and selection and the benefits of interviews, assessment and psychometric examinations as employee selection process" (Korsten, 2003). as depicted by the video below the process of recruitment and selection is well explained.
There are two types of recruitment/hiring.
1. 1. External.
2. 2. Internal
In deciding whether to hire from within or outside the
firm, should consider the nature and level of the job, characteristics of the
firm and industry, and a firm’s system of human resource management policies,
such as intensive recruitment and screening policies and training. Internal
hiring should be preferred to external hiring when knowledge and skills
specific to the firm are important, when promotions are crucial for motivating
current workers, when the costs of a hiring mistake are particularly large, and
when an additional vacancy (created when a worker switches jobs internally) is not
too costly (Devaro, 2016).
Hiring is one of the most important
decisions that organizations regularly make. When choosing between internal and
external hiring, managers need to consider their own organizational
environment, since some environments favour one method over the other.
Other relevant factors include as
said by Devaro (2016) are,
1.the nature of the job and its level
within the organization,
2.characteristics of the firm and
industry,
3.the interaction of internal and
external hiring
policies and other practices in a
firm’s human resources management system.
Types of internal
recruitment.
1 Transfers – According
to Stewmann (1986) transfer involves moving out persons from current jobs to
other similar jobs. These do not involve any change in designation,
responsibility or prestige. The numbers of persons do not increase with
transfers.
2. 2. Promotions - Promotions refer to
moving out persons to positions carrying better prestige, higher
responsibilities and more pay. The vacant higher positions may be filled up
from within the organization. A promotion does not increase the number of
persons in the organization (Cappelli, 2008).
3. 3. Present Employees:The
present staff of a priority area
unit enlightened regarding doubtless vacant positions. The
employees recommend their relations or persons intimately known to them.
Management is relieved of looking out prospective candidates (Robbins and
Coulter, 2005).
Types of external recruitment.
This is another method in hiring employees to an
organization. According to Cappelli (1999) external recruitment is the best
method to bring new skills and passionate resources into the organization. Eventhough
external recruitment can focus on a specific type of candidates to a specific
job , It can also be very costly and time consuming. Using company websites,
paper, radio and television advertisements, on compass college recruiting, employee
Referrals are some of the ways of external hiring.
In the Sri Lankan hospital setup the recruitment and selection
of various categories are different in the public and private sector. For this
discussion I would like to take into consideration the recruitment and
selection of minor staff personnel within the public and in contrast with the
private sector.
The government recruits minor staff personnel according to the
carder approval from the ministry Even though there is a minimum educational
qualification required there are no such specific job interviews or selection
tests carried out I.e psychometric tests, walk in interviews. Mostly the
appointments are given as a recommendation by the minister of health. Following
the first two years they will be subjected to an interview for confirmation in
service and in the following years will undergo an in service training to be
promoted to a hospital attendant.
Whereas in the private sector the candidates’ CVs are obtained
prior to a walk in interview and are recruited and selected according to there
IQ and there basic knowledge in patient care giving. Following which they are
given a basic training on their job and ways and methods in handling patients and
in giving optimized patient care. They will also be subjected to inservice
trainings through out and be promoted likewise.
The absence of proper recruitment and selection policies in the
government have incurred in the development of political based trade unions. Specially
when the jobs are given by a politician proper skilled recruitment is never
seen hence the patient care is never optimized.
When in contrast the same category of staff working in two different
systems appear to be more professional and updated in the private sector than
in the government sector.
CONCLUSION.
Recruitment
and selection plays a major role in the field of human resource management
where the right candidate should be chosen with the proper knowledge and skills
to that specific job. This unbiased selection process when properly done will
eventually up bring an organization’s development
and growth by new innovations and optimized service towards its customers. which
inturn correlates to the smooth functioning of an organization in the aspects
of its profitability and growth. As per the above example the recruitment
policies of supportive staff personnel to the public health sector should be
revised and proper psychometric tests and interviews should be planned prior to
handing over appointments. In contrast with the discussion above the job of
recruiting is a very important job in the organization as mentioned by Steve
Jobbs once.
Steve Jobs described the process of hiring top talent
as ‘the most important job’(Jager and Ortiz 1998).
References list:
1.Armstrong M. (2005), A Handbook of Human
Resources Management Practices, 9th edition, London: Kogan Page.
2 Cappelli, P. (2008). Talent on Demand:
Managing Talent in an Age of Uncertainty. Boston: Harvard Business Press.
3.Jager. R & Ortiz. R 1997. In the company of giants : Candid
conversations with visionaries of the digital world. Mc Graw Hill education,
U.S.A.
|
5.Elizabeth Linos &Joanne Reinhard (2015), Research article “A head for hiring”:The behavioural science of recruitment and selection.
6.Korsten A.D. (2003). Developing a training plan to ensure
employees keep up with the dynamics of facility management. Journal of
Facilities Management.
7.Lievens, Filip and Chapman, Derek. (2019)
Recruitment and selection: SAGE Handbook of Human Resource Management. p123-150.
Research Collection Lee Kong Chian School Of Business.
8.Robbins S.P., Coulter M.K. (2005). Management
(8th ed.). Upper Saddle River,NJ: Prentice Hall.
9.Stephen Bach, 2005. Managing human
resources: Personnel management in transition, 4th edition. Blackwell
publishing.
10.Stewman, S. 1986 "Demographic models of
internal labor markets." Administrative Science Quarterly, 31 p: 212-247.
Totally agree with your comment Mr Chulanga as mentioned with all the reasonings the most important task of the HR dept is recruiting and selecting the right individual for the right job.
ReplyDeleteHi Udana, the points you have mentioned here is very valid and clear. Further to support the topic I would like to share the following.
ReplyDeleteIn an organization the live wire or oxygen is its employees, it is extremely crucial to have a robust recruitment and selection process to recruit the right candidates and and place them at the right jobs. Failing to achieve this criteria, the organization will have to bear an extra cost and it will eventually have a direct impact to organizations growth and profitability. This is clearly proven by Ekwoaba, (2015) It mentions that, recruiting and selecting incompetent individuals has a significant negative cost that firms cannot afford. As a result, the ultimate goal of recruiting and selection inside the company is to achieve the number and quality of people necessary to meet the business's strategic objectives at a low cost.
Totally agree with you samantha. As mentioned by Carless (2007) hiring the best employees have benefited organizations stability and profitability..
DeleteHi Dr. Udhana, Agree with your post. Let me add the e-recruitment process to your heading ‘Types of external recruitment’. With the use of corporate websites, commercial job boards and agency sites and social media online or e-recruitment could be done. In this process advertising and providing information about jobs, online applying or applying by way of e-mail communication is done with the use of internet-based applications as described by Armstrong & Taylor (2014).
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteThank you Nilushi. Yes agree with your comment. With the globalisation if the organizations now a days e recruitment is becoming popular. "Today’s world is technology based world and we can feel its presence in each sphere of our lives.
DeleteConception of internet has changed our lives tremendously and it has also changed the perception of people
towards their work "(Bhupendra & Swati, 2015)
Hi Dr. Udana, you have covered all aspects of the reqruitment very well. External recruitment is a costly process that requires additional training and impacts employee morale, but further to ur reading on DeVaro (2020), this process has the potential to find qualified and successful candidates. Whereas In-house hiring, on the other hand, is seen as a very cost-effective way to motivate employees and spend little time adapting to new cultures. Identifying sources of recruitment is an important step in the course of the recruitment process. but most use internal and external sources, thereby increasing the chances of attracting candidates as well as prepared and competitive. (Muscalu, 2015) For an organization to succeed and survive, it must combine rational use of both sources of recruitment
ReplyDeleteThank you Chamara. True the whole recruitment process is costly and is risky if the right candidate is not chosen. So please check out my 4th blog where I have given a solution through e-recruiting. As said by Tyagi (2012, Automating the Recruitment Processes helps companies in implementing the Best Practices of recruitment and hiring the best talent available in the market cost effectively.
DeleteHello Udana, Well explained. Organizations mostly give priority to internal employees as it provides the opportunities for progress of employees and the use of the existing resources within the organization. Internal sources of recruitment are the finest & the stress-free way of selecting human resources as their work performance and other qualities are already known to the organization (Kapur, 2018).
ReplyDeleteThank you Muditha for the comment. Yes I also would wish to agree with your notion that internal hiring is better than external hiring at times. According to Muhareza [2019], he also explains that in a research carried out in the Nigerian police force the research findings led to the conclusion that internal recruitment methods positively influence employee performance.
DeleteHi Udana. A detailed and valid post. I fully agree. In addition, candidates frequently interpret the selection process as a sign of an organization's qualities; as a sort of realistic job preview that impacts the candidates decision to join or not join the organization, even if an offer has been made (Hausknecht et al.,2004).
ReplyDeleteTgank you and yes Ashanthi I totally agree with your insight. The employer brand and Organizational culture plays a huge role while entertaining new Recruiters. According to a study done by Khalid and Tariq (2015), they have concluded that the correlation analyses reveal that there is significant positive relationship between employer branding and the facilitated recruiting process
DeleteAgreed with you Udana , Selection is the process of selecting the correct type of candidate from a pool of candidates. Recruitment is the process of discovering and attracting possible candidates for future employment both within and outside the organization (Walker, 2009).
ReplyDeleteThank you Maheshani. Yes the recruitment and selection process is vital for the organization's success. With the help of the appropriate recruitment structures, the human resource management department will be capable of choosing the right employee. It is found that the more skilled and qualified individuals play an essential role in the growth of the organization (Abbasi et al, 2020).
DeleteHello Udana. Agreed on your post. There are two main requirement methods that commonly practiced which is internal and external. According to Cappelli (1999), extenal is the finest way to bring fresh talents and enthusiastic resources into the organization.
ReplyDeleteThank you Ruwan for your valuable insight. But if I may, would wish to emphasize on internal recruitment either horizontally by transfer or vertically by promotuons is better since the employee is already a part of the organizational culture and this process is very much cost effective and time saving. When promotions and lateral transfers are properly managed, they will significantly yield better performance results of employees (Muhereza,2019).
DeleteHi Dr. Udana, Agreed with your post. Recruitment is the process of identifying, choosing, and employing the best qualified individual for a job position from inside or outside of a business (Hamza et al., 2021).
ReplyDeleteThank you Janani and agree with you whole heartedly. Recruitment and selection are regarded as vital aspects, which need to be put into operation by the individuals, who are in leadership positions, in order to lead to well-being of the organization (Kapur,2020).
DeleteHi Udana, In addition to internal options, organizations also have the following external options to receive the information of candidates to meet organization’s recruitment needs (Armstrong 2012).
ReplyDeleteOnline Recruiting
Advertising
Recruitment Agencies
Job Centres
Recruitment consultants
Executive search consultants
Recruitment process outsourcing providers
Direct approaches to educational establishments
Hi Udana, adding to your subject ,'Good practice' in recruitment and selection,
ReplyDeleteIn the UK and in most industrialized countries,HR managers have tended for many years to advocate an approach to recruitment and selection which is widely believed to constitute 'good practice' its purpose is it to secure the best qualified and highest performance staff for the employer, while also being scrupulously fair to job applications. the approach is set out clearly and concisely by ACAS (2020) and CIPD (2020).
1Job Analysis
2 Job description
3 person specification
In parallel with competency analysis and competency framework
4 Recruitment
5 Selection
6. Appointment.
7. Induction
Hi Udana, I agree with your post, Recruitment is the process of discovering or selecting and hiring or best qualified candidate from inside or the process by which organizations locate and attract individuals to fill job vacancies (Anwar & Surarchith, 2015).
ReplyDeleteHi Udana,
ReplyDeletei agree with your blog.Efficiency in the recruitment processes generates productivity and builds a good working environment and good relations between the employees (Recruitment and Selection, 2016).
Hi Udana, In the process of recruitment and selection focus is on matching the capabilities and inclinations of prospective candidates against the demands and rewards inherent in a given job. A high preference is given for the educational and professional qualifications implies that the organizations surveyed are looking for qualified candidates, and the working experience is considered as a key factor in career transition to junior managerial role in Private sector of Sri Lanka (Wickramasinghe,2006)
ReplyDeleteIt is correct, recruitment and selection are parallel concepts, but they are deferent one to anther. Recruitment is related to searching potential and encouraging them to apply for an actual or anticipated vacancy. But selection is all about hiring employees by shortlisted candidates and giving a job role for them.
ReplyDelete